169 East 71st Street

Building Name

169 East 71st Street

Architect

John Sexton

Year(s) Built

1866

Designation

Upper East Side Historic District

169 East 71st Street
Project Information:

An Italianate style rowhouse designed by John Sexton and built in 1866. Application is to legalize reconstruction of the rear facade and construction of rooftop and rear yard additions in non-compliance with Certificate of Appropriateness 19-6008 (LPC 19-3420), issued December 7, 2016.

CB8 Hearing: 05/18/26 (Disapproved)
LPC Hearing: 07/14/26

See 2016 application here.

FRIENDS' Testimony:
When FRIENDS testified in 2016, we objected to the excessive height and depth of the proposed rear addition due to its encroachment on the historic rear "donut" and its adverse impact on neighboring properties. A decade later, we are deeply concerned to find that the building was constructed with even greater encroachment, blamed on a purported "construction error." The as-built third-floor rear wall extends approximately two feet beyond the approved limit, projecting past the neighboring façade and further compromising the adjacent property. This is not a minor deviation but a significant departure from the approved plans.

FRIENDS’ Preservation Committee strongly opposes any effort to legalize this non-compliant construction. Granting approval after the fact would undermine the integrity of the Commission's review process and establish a dangerous precedent by signaling that substantial departures from approved plans can be excused as construction errors.

LPC Hearing: July 14, 2026